Kiss and Make Up (Bachelors of Buttermilk Falls Book 3)
by Robyn Neeley
REVIEW POSTED ONLINE: AUG 01, 2026
Caitlin threw caution to the wind the night a magic spoon prophesied her boyfriend was meant for another woman and spent the night with the guy who humiliated her in high school. That night tied Josh and Caitlin together in the form of triplets but it will take a ghost with a mysterious history for them to work passed their hangups before they can become a true family.
AUTHOR: Robyn Neeley
PUB DATE: JAN 04, 2016
GENRES: Romantic Comedy, Magical Realism
CATEGORIES: Unexpected Pregnancy, Small Town, Witches, Childhood Crush, Ghosts, Fake Dating
REVIEW
What I liked:
Kiss and Make Up is a wonderful cozy small town romance with a dash of magic. The paranormal aspects add to the fun and intrigue rather than completely steal the show so the main focus of the story remains on the journey Caitlin and Josh must take to find love.
Fair Warning:
Caitlin and Josh are both headstrong and quick to jump to conclusions which does not work out well for the two of them.
Overall:
Grab Kiss and Make Up when you're in the mood for a quick romcom with a touch of magic. This is the third book in the Bachelors of Buttermilk Falls. I did not read the first two but the author does a good job of setting the stage so I felt like I was able to catch up on the existing character dynamics quickly.
Overall Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4/5)
Heat Index: 🔥🔥🔥 (3/5)